Like ankle braces with straps, lace up ankle braces provide greater ankle stability and support than an ankle sleeve but at the cost of less comfort. Compared to ankle braces with straps, lace ups are easier to apply (put on) since they do not involve the complex strapping patterns that you sometimes have to deal with when wearing braces with straps.
However, one potential disadvantage of lace ups relative to ankle braces with straps lies in their potential to restrict up and down ankle movement. This type of ankle movement (plantarflexion and dorsiflexion) is of key importance in actions like running or jumping. Some athletes notice this, although studies generally find little effect on performance in sports like basketball or volleyball.
Moreover, as the game or training session goes on, the laces can sometimes loosen, causing a decrease in the lateral support that is the primary reason for wearing the brace. To counter this problem, the user will need to re tie the laces every so often. This is akin to reapplying knee or ankle tape jobs regularly during games or practice.
Lace up braces are a good choice after mild to moderate sprains, for ankle instability, and for athletes in running and jumping sports who want to reduce the risk of another sprain.